Tuesday, October 20, 2020

Columbus and Human Nature

Genghis Khan, Christopher Columbus and Adolf Hitler to name a few are known for killing, but why? Why did Columbus set foot on the land he did, see beautiful and selfless people and decide to kill upwards of a million? Why was Adolf in such conflict with Jews, homosexuals and impaired that he ordered the death of close to 15 million? And Khan, to create the largest contiguous empire ever, killed 40 million individuals; In the name of conquest hundreds of millions of lives have been taken through history but why? Suppression of oppression clearly, but not so much when you really look at it closely. Not to say it's perfect but the adversaries could be exiled like the natives by the US government. But killing fellow humans is what these people did and I believe it is human nature. 

None of these men saw their adversaries as equal, just like how almost anyone can kill a bird and not live with remorse these men saw their adversaries as non equals, non human and thus killed in-affectionately. To see another man as unequal is arrogant, to be arrogant to another life and kill without moral weight is human nature. America bombed Japan when lets face it, "they messed with our boats" but we didn't Nuke Germany even though mid-way through the war we knew they were committing genocide. White America saw white Germany as equal and asian Japan as lesser then. 

In conclusion, I believe killing is in human nature just as much as arrogance does and when both combine in the name of conquest you see the mass murder and a lack of moral weight.


2 comments:

  1. Christopher Columbus was so set on getting what he wanted (gold) that he hurt huge quantities of people that were just trying to help him. Do not use this technique within rhetoric. Hurting the audience is a huge turnoff and will not successfully change their minds. Being selfish will reflect, so put your listeners first, and the rest will fall into place. I am glad we had to read the piece of literature on Christopher Columbus; it connected me more deeply to the successful techniques of rhetoric.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Honestly if I killed a bird I would be torn up about it for a long time. To me, any death is incredibly sad (no matter how irrelevant you think their life is). I think it is wrong to kill anyone, let alone people who were trying to help you. Columbus had no reason to kill the natives who were helping him other than greed. I definitely think that greed is apart of human nature which can lead to some unpleasant outcomes. Not everyone who is envious goes out and kills people, if this were the case I'd say that it could be human nature. We look back at people such as Hitler and think "wow that is one horrible viscous human being". If it was human nature I don't think that people would view him how they do.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.

Thank You For Arguing

 Now that the semester is finally coming to an end, I wanted to do book summary and review. Throughout the whole book Jay Heinrichs walks yo...